Stephen M. Quilty, et al. v. Envision Healthcare Corp, et al., No. 8:18-cv-00341-VMC-CPT

Middle District of Florida

Class Period: February 08, 2018 – Present

Class: All commercially insured beneficiaries that live or reside in Florida who sought emergency medical care at an in-network hospital managed by Defendants and who were subsequently balance-billed for the cost of that care.


Headshot: Frederic Fox

Frederic S. Fox

Laurence D. King
Headshot: Donald Hall

Donald R. Hall
Matthew George

Matthew B. George
profile headshot placeholder

Aaron L. Schwartz

Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer LLP announces that a class action was filed Thursday, February 8, 2018, in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida against physician staffing firm Envision Healthcare Corporation and its affiliates, EmCare Holdings Inc., Emcare Inc., and Baxley Emergency Physician Services LLC, (collectively, “Envision”).  Plaintiff’s Complaint alleges that Envision manages hospital emergency departments in Florida, which includes treating patients and providing administrative services, such as billing and collections for emergency medical services rendered. The complaint generally alleges that Envision violated Florida law when “balance-billing” patients for emergency medical services. 

The Complaint alleges that “balance-billing” occurs when a healthcare provider holds a patient liable for any remaining charges not covered by the patient’s health insurance company. Balance-billing most often occurs when a patient receives medical care outside their insurance network.  However, the Complaint alleges that even when patients obtain emergency treatment at an in-network hospital, they may still be balance-billed because, unbeknownst to the patient at the time of treatment, the treating physicians were affiliated with or employed by Envision.  Accordingly, even patients that sought in-network healthcare may receive surprise medical bills weeks or months later.  The Complaint alleges that Florida is one of several states that has passed laws to prohibit providers, like Envision, from balance-billing emergency room patients due to their lack of choice in obtaining in-network medical treatment in emergency situations.  

According to the Complaint, Envision has consistently ignored Florida’s balance-billing law by continuing to deceptively and fraudulently bill and collect payments from former patients.  As a result of Envision’s actions, the Complaint alleges that former patients are owed damages for amounts collected by Envision for its unlawful balance-billed charges. Plaintiff seeks damages on behalf of all Florida patients impacted by Envision’s practices and an injunction preventing Envision and its affiliates from balance-billing patients in the future.  

The patient-consumers are represented by Frederic S. Fox, Laurence D. King, Donald R. Hall, Matthew B. George, and Aaron L. Schwartz of Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer LLP, and Marc A. Wites of the Wites Law Firm.  Plaintiff’s counsel has extensive experience in prosecuting class actions and recovering damages for affected consumers. 

Plaintiff’s counsel is also investigating whether Envision violated balance-billing laws in other states, including California, Illinois, and New Jersey.  Consumers who would like more information about this lawsuit or investigation should visit or call Aaron L. Schwartz at (800) 290-1952.

For more information about this press release or lawsuit, please contact: 

Frederic S. Fox
850 Third Avenue, 14th Floor
New York, New York 10022
(800) 290-1952
(212) 687-1980
Fax: (212) 687-7714

Laurence D. King
350 Sansome Street, Suite 400 
San Francisco, California 94104
(415) 772-4700
Fax:  (415) 772-4707

Marc A. Wites
4400 North Federal Highway
Lighthouse Point, FL 33064
Telephone: (954) 526-2729

This press release may be considered Attorney Advertising in some jurisdictions under the applicable law and ethical rules.


Connect with Kaplan Fox.

Receive a complimentary case review now.